My Blog List

Sunday, October 10, 2010

Blog 6: What is a Hero?

Brandon Miller
Blog 6 Hero?




Defining a hero is hard. In American culture, we define a hero as someone who is hard working, honest, helpful, intellectual, dependable/reliable, and puts others life's above them self's because it is 'the right thing to do'. But this is hardly the rule. Most of the time, a hero is really just someone who was at the right place at the right time and decided to help. That is exactly the case in the Movie Hero, where we ask, what is a hero and who can be one.


First off, anyone can be a 'hero'. It is not something you are born with, its not in your blood, and you cant train to be a hero. There is no test, or special right of passage. There is no wrong or right person to be a hero. Hero proves this by having Bernie Laplante a low life, con artiest, who clearly only looks out for himself. And yet he is the hero of the movie, who pulls 54 people out of a crashed burning plane. Given the description of a hero, you would NEVER expect this lieing, excuses making, thief to do anything heroic. And yet he does. Does his characteristics, make him any less of a hero? Even though he saved so many people, does his past actions make him any less of a hero?


Now, lets take another character, John Bubber. A Vietnam war veteran, who is now homeless and living in his car. He constantly thinks of others, he helps Bernie when he needs a ride and even decides to to give someone else a shoe when he could have used it. Would you ever expect him to claim HE was the one that pulled all those people out of the plane and take the Million dollar reword? The only person to try and stick their neck out for others, and has any quality's that would make for a hero, is the one that tells the lie in order to get the money. He puts up this whole charade and continues to lie about saving the people, mean while Bernie is serving time in jail and could really use the money.


Now, lets take a deeper look at this. John was wrong for doing what he did, But as they say there is a method to the madness. One thing that needs to be considered is that, John was homeless and kind hearted. He was not some corporate big shot, who already had a home and money. He could really use the million dollars, and he could have helped others with it. He still shouldn't have done it. Now with Bernie He also could have used the money and he earned it. And even with his crocked past, he still deserved it for helping them.


So, what is a hero? Because Bernie certainly dose not fit the bill. But even so he still risked his life for the sake of others. Not to mention Bubber who had the makings of the hero still did something wrong but tried to make it right. Lets say it was Hitler who saved those people from the plane. Would he still be consider a hero despite everything else he has done? Yes, no, I don't know. After doing this assignment and thinking about it, I now have no idea what makes a hero.

3 comments:

  1. Ture John Bubber shouldn't have lied, but look what happen in the long run. People were actually inspired to do "good" even if it's a short breif of time. If the public knew the truth people would not only be heart broken, but continue to live in a "Dog eat Dog" world.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I dont think Bernie was the real hero even though he did commit the heroic act he was just there at the right time and the little boys cry's for his father made Bernie want to save only his dad. Because when on the Plane Bernie ask the guys name he said Smith and then Bernie says "FUCK THAT IM LOOKING FOR FLETCHER" basically saying tough shit man good luck getting out because im busy and could really care less about you. John Bubber is a theif and if he was such a good guy he would have stuck to the rules and not lie like he did. To answer your question on what is a hero there's no such thing there are acts we consider heroic like saving kittens out of trees and throwing shoes at George W. Bush but a hero is someone who always commits these heroics act.Think about it if you stopped a theif and rescued all the hostages they'd call you a hero, but are you going to steal a police radio like Peter Parker in Spider-Man and go around stopping bank robberies?? I sure hope not because it would just get me mad when you realize that its really annoying.

    ReplyDelete
  3. above me is my other blog i was signed into the wrong oneLOL

    I dont think Bernie was the real hero even though he did commit the heroic act he was just there at the right time and the little boys cry's for his father made Bernie want to save only his dad. Because when on the Plane Bernie ask the guys name he said Smith and then Bernie says "FUCK THAT IM LOOKING FOR FLETCHER" basically saying tough shit man good luck getting out because im busy and could really care less about you. John Bubber is a theif and if he was such a good guy he would have stuck to the rules and not lie like he did. To answer your question on what is a hero there's no such thing there are acts we consider heroic like saving kittens out of trees and throwing shoes at George W. Bush but a hero is someone who always commits these heroics act.Think about it if you stopped a theif and rescued all the hostages they'd call you a hero, but are you going to steal a police radio like Peter Parker in Spider-Man and go around stopping bank robberies?? I sure hope not because it would just get me mad when you realize that its really annoying.

    ReplyDelete